EU’s disdain for voters
Tuesday, July 15th, 2008[Quote:]
A letter writer to the London Times put his finger on it. “Can anybody explain to me,” he asked, “what is the difference between democracy in Zimbabwe and democracy in the European Union?”
In Zimbabwe, back in March, Robert Mugabe called an election which he was sure he would win. But despite widespread intimidation and vote rigging, he lost. His Zanu-PF party lost its majority in parliament, and Mugabe himself was defeated by Morgan Tsvangirai in the presidential race.
But Mugabe refused to accept the result and organised a rerun. This time he made sure the result would be the right one.
The point the letter writer was making is that something similar keeps happening in European Union referendums. Whenever voters reject a proposal put forward by Europe’s political elite, they either get ignored, or they are told to vote again until they get it right. It happened to the Danes in 2000 when they rejected the Maastricht Treaty and a second referendum was called. The Irish then rejected the Nice Treaty in 2001 and had to have a rerun. And now it’s happening again after French, Dutch and Irish voters have rejected the Lisbon Treaty.
Note how Sarkozy manages to redefine the word “listen”:
[Quote:]
Ireland will have to hold a second referendum on the Lisbon Treaty, French President Nicolas Sarkozy has said.
[..]
Minister for Foreign Affairs Michael Martin said President Sarkozy is coming to Ireland to ‘listen’, and not to impose any solutions.
And don’t you love how ignoring the wishes of the voters is now called “being more transparent and accountable”? Take a look:
[Quote:]
The first reason is that the ratification of the Lisbon Treaty and its successful implementation will pave the way for a more democratic and more transparent Union. The first reason is that the ratification of the Lisbon Treaty and its successful implementation will pave the way for a more democratic and more transparent Union. We will be more accountable and responsive to our citizens. We will be more accountable and responsive to our citizens. And they will be better able to exercise their rights under the Charter of Fundamental Rights. The Charter reinforces our Union of law. The Charter reinforces our Union of law.
Past experience suggests the Irish will either be told to vote again, or their government will find a pretext for signing a slightly-amended version of the treaty without calling another referendum.
I wonder if Mugabe is taking notes?






