« | Home | Recent Comments | Categories | »

Do Drones Undermine Democracy? – NYTimes.com

Posted on January 22nd, 2012 at 21:48 by Desiato in category: Commentary -- Write a comment

[Quote]:

There is not a single new manned combat aircraft under research and development at any major Western aerospace company, and the Air Force is training more operators of unmanned aerial systems than fighter and bomber pilots combined. In 2011, unmanned systems carried out strikes from Afghanistan to Yemen. The most notable of these continuing operations is the not-so-covert war in Pakistan, where the United States has carried out more than 300 drone strikes since 2004. Yet this operation has never been debated in Congress; more than seven years after it began, there has not even been a single vote for or against it. This campaign is not carried out by the Air Force; it is being conducted by the C.I.A. This shift affects everything from the strategy that guides it to the individuals who oversee it civilian political appointees and the lawyers who advise them civilians rather than military officers . It also affects how we and our politicians view such operations. President Obama’s decision to send a small, brave Navy Seal team into Pakistan for 40 minutes was described by one of his advisers as “the gutsiest call of any president in recent history.” Yet few even talk about the decision to carry out more than 300 drone strikes in the very same country. I do not condemn these strikes; I support most of them. What troubles me, though, is how a new technology is short-circuiting the decision-making process for what used to be the most important choice a democracy could make. Something that would have previously been viewed as a war is simply not being treated like a war.

  1. What democracy?

  2. Sue may be going farther than I would, but honestly, this just sounds like what the CIA has been doing for the last 50 years. What does drone warfare have to do with it?

  3. I consider drone warfare to be the beginning of the end. I think killing with drones is similar to murder, and it’s likely to encourage further military adventures. I guess one could consider bombs in the same way. Maybe, we should just stop the killing.

previous post: So rong Harry Potter!

next post: U.S. economy unlikely to fully recover: Carney